Archive for the ‘Clusters’ Category

Building a 10-Server FreeBSD Jail Cluster Running a LAMP (Linux / Apache / MySQL / Perl / PHP / Python) Stack

Wednesday, March 25th, 2026

building-freebsd-jails-cluster-running-linux-apache-10-cluster-high-availability-with-mariadb-perl-php-howto

Virtualization and workload isolation are foundational to modern infrastructure.
While most teams today default to container platforms like Docker and orchestration systems such as Kubernetes, an older and highly capable alternative exists in the form of jails from FreeBSD.

FreeBSD jails provide lightweight OS-level isolation, allowing multiple independent userland environments to run on a single host. Introduced long before containers became mainstream, jails were designed with a strong focus on security, simplicity, and performance.
Despite their maturity and robustness, they are less commonly used today, largely due to the rapid rise of container ecosystems and cloud-native tooling.

Choosing between jails and containers is not simply a matter of “old vs new,” but rather a trade-off between control and simplicity versus portability and ecosystem support.

Short Comparison of FreeBSD jails and Containers ( Pros and Cons )

Advantages of FreeBSD Jails

a. Strong, simple isolation

Jails provide a clear and tightly integrated security boundary within the FreeBSD kernel. Their design is straightforward, reducing the risk of misconfiguration compared to layered container security models.

freebsd_jails_infographic_diagram

b. High performance

Because jails operate very close to the base system, they deliver near-native performance with minimal overhead—especially beneficial for networking and I/O-heavy workloads.

c. Operational simplicity

There are fewer component moving parts (easier to maintain and debbug):

  • No separate container runtime
  • No image layers
  • No complex orchestration requirements

This makes jails appealing for stable, long-running systems.

d. Predictability and stability

FreeBSD’s conservative, design philosophy results in systems that are highly stable over long periods, that is ideal for infrastructure roles like: storage or networking.

Disadvantages of FreeBSD Jails

a. Limited portability

Not neceserry a huge disadvantage but still,
Jails are tied to FreeBSD. Unlike containers, they cannot be easily moved across different operating systems or cloud platforms.


b. Smaller ecosystem

FBSD Jails is not full equivallent to:

  • Container registries (like Docker Hub)
  • Massive orchestration ecosystems (similar things has to be done with scripts and customizations)
  • Broad third-party integrations

This can slow down a bit development and deployment workflows. Though for a matured Applications that are once well tuned with jails that can be not a real probblem.

Note that though a con, this can also be a pros, as once you tune up an App for it becomes easier to maintain.

c. Less automation tooling

While tools exist, they are not as standardized or widely adopted as container-based CI/CD pipelines.

d. Harder to find people for it
 

Most developers and DevOps engineers are trained in container technologies, making hiring and collaboration easier in container-based environments. However for senior hard core sysadmins and system engineers that could be also advantage as not so many people have an indepth insight with both freebsd and fbsd jails.

This guide walks through a practical, production-style setup: 10 FreeBSD servers, each running isolated jails that host a classic LAMP stack (Linux, here replaced by FreeBSD, Apache, MySQL/MariaDB, PHP).
However still the use of companies or individuals who choose freebsd jails aim to better focus is on repeatability, clean architecture, and operational sanity, not just getting it to run once.

Architecture Overview of sample FBSD Cluster

Our Goal:

  • 10 physical or virtual servers
  • Each server runs multiple jails
  • Each jail runs a LAMP app instance
  • Load balancing across nodes (to have a High Availability Cluster like setup)

Host Setup:

  • 2 × load balancer nodes (nginx or HAProxy)
  • 6 × application nodes (Apache + PHP in jails)
  • 2 × database nodes (MariaDB primary/replica)

All systems run FreeBSD, using native jails for isolation.

1. Base FreeBSD Installation (All 10 Servers)

Install FreeBSD on each machine (minimal install is fine).

Update system:

# freebsd-update fetch install
# pkg update && pkg upgrade -y

Install base tools:

# pkg install -y sudo vim bash git

2. Install Jail Management tool (iocage)

We’ll use iocage, a modern jail manager.

# pkg install -y iocage
# sysrc iocage_enable="YES"
# service iocage start

Activate ZFS (recommended):

# zpool create zroot /dev/da0

Initialize iocage:

# iocage activate zroot
# iocage fetch

3. Create a Reusable Jail Template

Instead of building each jail manually, create a golden template.

# iocage create -n lamp-template -r 13.2-RELEASE ip4_addr="vnet0|10.0.0.10/24" boot=off
# iocage start lamp-template
# iocage console lamp-template

4. Install LAMP Stack Inside the Jail

Inside the jail:

4.1. Install Apache

# pkg install -y apache24
# sysrc apache24_enable="YES"

4.2. Install MariaDB

# pkg install -y mariadb106-server
# sysrc mysql_enable="YES"

Initialize DB:

service mysql-server start
mysql_secure_installation

4.3. Install PHP pre-compiled ports

# pkg install -y php82 php82-mysqli php82-mbstring php82-opcache


Configure Apache to use PHP:

# echo 'LoadModule php_module libexec/apache24/libphp.so' >> /usr/local/etc/apache24/httpd.conf
# echo 'AddType application/x-httpd-php .php' >> /usr/local/etc/apache24/httpd.conf

5. Test LAMP Stack works OK

Create a test file:

# echo "<?php phpinfo(); ?>" > /usr/local/www/apache24/data/index.php

Start services:

service apache24 start

Visit the jail IP and confirm PHP (page output) works in Firefox / Chrome Browser.

6. Convert Template into Clones

Stop Jail and snapshot:

iocage stop lamp-template
iocage snapshot lamp-template@base

Clone for production:

iocage clone lamp-template -n app01 ip4_addr="vnet0|10.0.0.21/24"
iocage clone lamp-template -n app02 ip4_addr="vnet0|10.0.0.22/24"

Repeat across servers and once working create a small shell script to run as a cron job to create backups automated.

Each server might run 5 up to 20 jails depending on resources.

7. Networking Between Jails

Use VNET for proper isolation:

Enable bridge on host:

# ifconfig bridge0 create
# ifconfig bridge0 addm em0 up

Assign jail interfaces automatically via iocage.

8.  Load Balancing Layer

On 2 dedicated nodes, install nginx:

# pkg install -y nginx
# sysrc nginx_enable="YES"

Example config:

http {
    upstream backend {
        server 10.0.0.21;
        server 10.0.0.22;
        server 10.0.1.21;
        server 10.0.1.22;
    }

    server {
        listen 80;

        location / {
            proxy_pass http://backend;
        }
    }
}

9. Database Strategy

You have few options to choose from:

a. Use Centralized DB

  • Dedicated DB jails on 2 nodes
  • Primary + replica

b. Use Per-node DB (simpler)

  • Each jail has its own MariaDB
  • Use app-level replication if needed

10. Automation Across 10 Servers

Use tools like:

  • Ansible
  • SSH scripts
  • ZFS replication

Example (simple parallel execution loop) or use a set of scripts to handle updating with some Ansible Playbooks or Puppet:

# for host in server{1..10}; do
  ssh $host "pkg update"
done

Few more Operational Tips to consider

a. Tune up setup / Do Resource management

  • Limit jail CPU/memory using rctl
  • Avoid overcommitting RAM

b. Use Centralized Logging

c. Do regular jail Backups

  • Use ZFS snapshots to backup each of the Jails:

# zfs snapshot zroot/iocage/jails/app01@backup

d. Tighten Security

  • Disable root SSH
  • Use PF firewall on host
  • Keep jails minimal

e. Do a Further Scaling Strategy

  • Add more servers -> replicate template
  • Add more jails -> clone snapshots
  • Scale horizontally via load balancer

Summary and Last Thoughts

When Choose FBSD Jails and when Containers

  • Use jails when you control the infrastructure, need maximum efficiency, and value simplicity (e.g., appliances, CDNs, storage systems).
  • Use containers when portability, scalability, and integration with modern DevOps workflows are critical.

This setup plays to the strengths of FreeBSD jails:

1. Performance: near-native speed
2.Isolation: strong and predictable
3. Simplicity: fewer layers than container stacks

FreeBSD jails remain a powerful and efficient isolation mechanism, particularly well-suited for controlled, performance-sensitive environments. Containers, however, dominate in modern application deployment due to their flexibility and ecosystem. The choice ultimately depends on whether you prioritize system-level control or platform-level convenience.

You won’t get the ecosystem of tools like Docker or Kubernetes, but you gain control, stability, and efficiency, which is exactly why companies like Netflix still rely on this model in critical infrastructure.

 

How to create PCS / Corosync High Availability Cluster config backup and migrate to new Virtual Machines

Thursday, October 26th, 2023

pcs-pcmk-internals-explained-picture

The aim of this article is to illustrate how to literally migrate a an Haproxy PCS Pacemaker / Corosync Cluster configurations from old Virtual Machines that due to time passed become unsupported (The Operating System end of life (EOF)) has reached to a new ones. 
This is quite a complex task especially as you usually need to setup the Hypervisor hosts with VMWare / Xen / KVM / OpenVZ or whatever kind of virtualization is to be used. Then setup the correct network interfaces IPs failover the heartbeat lines over which the cluster will work to prevent Split Brain scenartions, the Network Bonding interfaces to guarantee a higher amount of higher availability as well as physically install and update all the cluster software on the new built Linux hosts that will be members of the new cluster in setup. 

All this configuration from scratch of a PCS Corosync cluster is a very lenght topic which I'll try to cover in some of my next articles. In short to migrate the cluster from old machines to new once all this predescribed steps are in line. 
You will need to.


1. Create backup of old cluster configuration
2. Migrate the backup to a new built VM Machine hosts
3. Import the cluster configuration into the PCS Cluster.


Bear in mind that this article discusses a migration of CentOS Linux release 7.9.2009 with its shipped versions of corosync / pacemaker and pcs 

How to create cluster config backup and migrate to new VM

1. Dump cluster assuming that is a Quality Assuare or Pre – Production host  to create full cluster config backup

[root@old-cluster-machine ~]# pcs config backup old-cluster-machine.pcs.config.bak

2. Dump cluster Production full configuration

[root@old-cluster-machine1 ~]# pcs config backup old-cluster-machine1.pcs.config.bak

This command will output a backup of 

old-cluster-machine1.pcs.config.bak.tar.bz2

3. Migrate a cluster identical config to the new Virtual machines

Usually this moval of produced backup files with pcs config backup  commands can be copied with something like FTP / SFTP  or SSL-ed / TLS-ed protocol. However if you have to move the configuration files from a paranoid Citrix environment that doesn't allow you to have any SFTP / SSH or FTP kind of transfer protocol from the location where the old config lays to the new ones. 
A simple encoding of the binary format dumped configuration to plain text files can be done and files, can be moved via a simple copy / paste operation (a bit of a hack) 🙂

Encode the cluster config to be able to migrate configuration in plain text via a simple Copy / Paste operation.

 

[root@old-cluster-machine ~]# base64 config backup old-cluster-machine.pcs.config.bak > old-cluster-machine.pcs.config.bak.tgz.b64

[root@old-cluster-machine1 ~]# base64 old-cluster-machine1.pcs.config.bak.tar.bz2 > old-cluster-machine1.pcs.config.bak.tgz.b64
[root@old-cluster-machine ~]# cat  old-cluster-machine.pcs.config.bak.tgz.b64

(Copy output and Paste to new host VM) /root/haproxy-cluster-backup)

[root@old-cluster-machine1 ~]# cat old-cluster-machine1.pcs.config.bak.tgz.b64 


(Copy output and Paste to new host VM) /root/haproxy-cluster-backup)

Login to the new hosts, where configs has to be migrated and restore the files with base64

For QA / Preprod to restore backup config

[root@dkv-newqa-vm ~]# mkdir /root/haproxy-cluster-backup
[root@dkv-newqa-vm ~]# cd /root/haproxy-cluster-backup
[root@dkv-newqa-vm ~]# base64 -d old-cluster-machine.config.bak.tgz.b64 > old-cluster-machine.pcs.config.bak.tar.bz2
[root@dkv-newqa-vm ~]#  tar -jxvf old-cluster-machine.pcs.config.bak.tar.bz2
ak.tar.bz2
version.txt
pcs_settings.conf
corosync.conf
cib.xml
pacemaker_authkey
uidgid.d/

 

For Prod to restore backup config

[root@dkv-newprod-vm  ~]# mkdir /root/haproxy-cluster-backup
[root@dkv-newprod-vm ~]# cd /root/haproxy-cluster-backup
[root@dkv-newprod-vm ~]# base64 -d old-cluster-machine.config.bak.tgz.b64 > old-cluster-machine1.pcs.config.bak.tar.bz2
ak.tar.bz2
version.txt
pcs_settings.conf
corosync.conf
cib.xml
pacemaker_authkey
uidgid.d/


N!B! An Useful hin is on RHEL 8 Linux's shipped pcs command version has also a very useful command with which you can simply dump completly the config of the cluster in straight commands which you can run directly on the new VM machines where you have migrated.

The command to print out commands that would add existing cluster resources on Redhat 8:

# pcs resource config –output-format=cmd

Another useful command for cluster migration is cibadmin

i.e. to dump cluster xml config

#cibadmin –q > cluster.xml

Later you can import the prior xml dump with it.

# cibadmin –replace –xml-file cib.xml

 

How to update expiring OpenSSL certificates without downtime on haproxy Pacemaker / Corosync PCS Cluster

Tuesday, July 19th, 2022

pcm-active-passive-scheme-corosync-pacemaker-openssl-renew-fix-certificate

Lets say you have a running PCS Haproxy cluster with 2 nodes and you have already a configuration in haproxy with a running VIP IP and this proxies
are tunneling traffic to a webserver such as Apache or directly to an Application and you end up in the situation where the configured certificates,
are about to expire soon. As you can guess having the cluster online makes replacing the old expiring SSL certificate with a new one relatively easy
task. But still there are a couple of steps to follow which seems easy but systemizing them and typing them down takes some time and effort.
In short you need to check the current certificates installed on the haproxy inside the Haproxy configuration files,
in my case the haproxy cluster was running 2 haproxy configs haproxyprod.cfg and haproxyqa.cfg and the certificates configured are places inside this
configuration.

Hence to do the certificate update, I had to follow few steps:

A. Find the old certificate key or generate a new one that will be used later together with the CSR (Certificate Request File) to generate the new Secure Socket Layer
certificate pair.
B. Either use the old .CSR (this is usually placed inside the old .CRT certificate file) or generate a new one
C. Copy those .CSR file to the Copy / Paste buffer and place it in the Website field on the step to fill in a CSR for the new certificate on the Domain registrer
such as NameCheap / GoDaddy / BlueHost / Entrust etc.
D. Registrar should then be able to generate files like the the new ServerCertificate.crt, Public Key Root Certificate Authority etc.
E. You should copy and store these files in some database for future perhaps inside some database such as .xdb
for example you can se the X – Certificate and Key management xca (google for xca download).
F. Copy this certificate and place it on the top of the old .crt file that is configured on the haproxies for each domain for which you have configured it on node2
G. standby node1 so the cluster sends the haproxy traffic to node2 (where you should already have the new configured certificate)
H. Prepare the .crt file used by haproxy by including the new ServerCertificate.crt content on top of the file on node1 as well
I. unstandby node1
J. Check in browser by accessing the URL the certificate is the new one based on the new expiry date that should be extended in future
K. Check the status of haproxy
L. If necessery check /var/log/haproxy.log on both clusters to check all works as expected

haserver_cluster_sample

Below are the overall commands to use to complete below jobs

Old extracted keys and crt files are located under /home/username/new-certs

1. Check certificate expiry start / end dates


[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl s_client -connect 10.40.18.88:443 2>/dev/null| openssl x509 -noout -enddate
notAfter=Aug 12 12:00:00 2022 GMT

2. Find Certificate location taken from /etc/haproxy/haproxyprod.cfg / /etc/haproxy/haproxyqa.cfg

# from Prod .cfg
   bind 10.40.18.88:443 ssl crt /etc/haproxy/certs/www.your-domain.com.crt ca-file /etc/haproxy/certs/ccnr-ca-prod.crt 
 

# from QA .cfg

    bind 10.50.18.87:443 ssl crt /etc/haproxy/certs/test.your-domain.com.crt ca-file /etc/haproxy/certs

3. Check  CRT cert expiry


# for haproxy-serv02 qa :443 listeners

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl s_client -connect 10.50.18.87:443 2>/dev/null| openssl x509 -noout -enddate 
notAfter=Dec  9 13:24:00 2029 GMT

 

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl x509 -enddate -noout -in /etc/haproxy/certs/www.your-domain.com.crt
notAfter=Aug 12 12:00:00 2022 GMT

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl x509 -noout -dates -in /etc/haproxy/certs/www.your-domain.com.crt 
notBefore=May 13 00:00:00 2020 GMT
notAfter=Aug 12 12:00:00 2022 GMT


[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl x509 -noout -dates -in /etc/haproxy/certs/other-domain.your-domain.com.crt 
notBefore=Dec  6 13:52:00 2019 GMT
notAfter=Dec  9 13:52:00 2022 GMT

4. Check public website cert expiry in a Chrome / Firefox or Opera browser

In a Chrome browser go to updated URLs:

https://www.your-domain/login

https://test.your-domain/login

https://other-domain.your-domain/login

and check the certs

5. Login to one of haproxy nodes haproxy-serv02 or haproxy-serv01

Check what crm_mon (the cluster resource manager) reports of the consistancy of cluster and the belonging members
you should get some output similar to below:

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# crm_mon
Stack: corosync
Current DC: haproxy-serv01 (version 1.1.23-1.el7_9.1-9acf116022) – partition with quorum
Last updated: Fri Jul 15 16:39:17 2022
Last change: Thu Jul 14 17:36:17 2022 by root via cibadmin on haproxy-serv01

2 nodes configured
6 resource instances configured

Online: [ haproxy-serv01 haproxy-serv02 ]

Active resources:

 ccnrprodlbvip  (ocf::heartbeat:IPaddr2):       Started haproxy-serv01
 ccnrqalbvip    (ocf::heartbeat:IPaddr2):       Started haproxy-serv01
 Clone Set: haproxyqa-clone [haproxyqa]
     Started: [ haproxy-serv01 haproxy-serv02 ]
 Clone Set: haproxyprod-clone [haproxyprod]
     Started: [ haproxy-serv01 haproxy-serv02 ]


6. Create backup of existing certificates before proceeding to regenerate expiring
On both haproxy-serv01 / haproxy-serv02 run:

 

# cp -vrpf /etc/haproxy/certs/ /home/username/etc-haproxy-certs_bak_$(date +%d_%y_%m)/


7. Find the .key file etract it from latest version of file CCNR-Certificates-DB.xdb

Extract passes from XCA cert manager (if you're already using XCA if not take the certificate from keypass or wherever you have stored it.

+ For XCA cert manager ccnrlb pass
Find the location of the certificate inside the .xdb place etc.

+++++ www.your-domain.com.key file +++++

—–BEGIN PUBLIC KEY—–

—–END PUBLIC KEY—–


# Extracted from old file /etc/haproxy/certs/www.your-domain.com.crt
 

—–BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY—–

—–END RSA PRIVATE KEY—–


+++++

8. Renew Generate CSR out of RSA PRIV KEY and .CRT

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl x509 -noout -fingerprint -sha256 -inform pem -in www.your-domain.com.crt
SHA256 Fingerprint=24:F2:04:F0:3D:00:17:84:BE:EC:BB:54:85:52:B7:AC:63:FD:E4:1E:17:6B:43:DF:19:EA:F4:99:L3:18:A6:CD

# for haproxy-serv01 prod :443 listeners

[root@haproxy-serv02 certs]# openssl x509 -x509toreq -in www.your-domain.com.crt -out www.your-domain.com.csr -signkey www.your-domain.com.key


9. Move (Standby) traffic from haproxy-serv01 to ccnrl0b2 to test cert works fine

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# pcs cluster standby haproxy-serv01


10. Proceed the same steps on haproxy-serv01 and if ok unstandby

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# pcs cluster unstandby haproxy-serv01


11. Check all is fine with openssl client with new certificate


Check Root-Chain certificates:

# openssl verify -verbose -x509_strict -CAfile /etc/haproxy/certs/ccnr-ca-prod.crt -CApath  /etc/haproxy/certs/other-domain.your-domain.com.crt{.pem?)
/etc/haproxy/certs/other-domain.your-domain.com.crt: OK

# openssl verify -verbose -x509_strict -CAfile /etc/haproxy/certs/thawte-ca.crt -CApath  /etc/haproxy/certs/www.your-domain.com.crt
/etc/haproxy/certs/www.your-domain.com.crt: OK

################# For other-domain.your-domain.com.crt ##############
Do the same

12. Check cert expiry on /etc/haproxy/certs/other-domain.your-domain.com.crt

# for haproxy-serv02 qa :15443 listeners
[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl s_client -connect 10.40.18.88:15443 2>/dev/null| openssl x509 -noout -enddate
notAfter=Dec  9 13:52:00 2022 GMT

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]#  openssl x509 -enddate -noout -in /etc/haproxy/certs/other-domain.your-domain.com.crt 
notAfter=Dec  9 13:52:00 2022 GMT


Check also for 
+++++ other-domain.your-domain.com..key file +++++
 

—–BEGIN PUBLIC KEY—–

—–END PUBLIC KEY—–

 


# Extracted from /etc/haproxy/certs/other-domain.your-domain.com.crt
 

—–BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY—–

—–END RSA PRIVATE KEY—–


+++++

13. Standby haproxy-serv01 node 1

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# pcs cluster standby haproxy-serv01

14. Renew Generate CSR out of RSA PRIV KEY and .CRT for second domain other-domain.your-domain.com

# for haproxy-serv01 prod :443 renew listeners
[root@haproxy-serv02 certs]# openssl x509 -x509toreq -in other-domain.your-domain.com.crt  -out domain-certificate.com.csr -signkey domain-certificate.com.key


And repeat the same steps e.g. fill the CSR inside the domain registrer and get the certificate and move to the proxy, check the fingerprint if necessery
 

[root@haproxy-serv01 certs]# openssl x509 -noout -fingerprint -sha256 -inform pem -in other-domain.your-domain.com.crt
SHA256 Fingerprint=60:B5:F0:14:38:F0:1C:51:7D:FD:4D:C1:72:EA:ED:E7:74:CA:53:A9:00:C6:F1:EB:B9:5A:A6:86:73:0A:32:8D


15. Check private key's SHA256 checksum

# openssl pkey -in terminals-priv.KEY -pubout -outform pem | sha256sum
# openssl x509 -in other-domain.your-domain.com.crt -pubkey -noout -outform pem | sha256sum

# openssl pkey -in  www.your-domain.com.crt-priv-KEY -pubout -outform pem | sha256sum

# openssl x509 -in  www.your-domain.com.crt -pubkey -noout -outform pem | sha256sum


16. Check haproxy config is okay before reload cert


# haproxy -c -V -f /etc/haproxy/haproxyprod.cfg
Configuration file is valid


# haproxy -c -V -f /etc/haproxy/haproxyqa.cfg
Configuration file is valid

Good so next we can the output of status of certificate

17.Check old certificates are reachable via VIP IP address

Considering that the cluster VIP Address is lets say 10.40.18.88 and running one of the both nodes cluster to check it do something like:
 

# curl -vvI https://10.40.18.88:443|grep -Ei 'start date|expire date'


As output you should get the old certificate


18. Reload Haproxies for Prod and QA on node1 and node2

You can reload the haproxy clusters processes gracefully something similar to kill -HUP but without loosing most of the current established connections with below cmds:

Login on node1 (haproxy-serv01) do:

# /usr/sbin/haproxy -f /etc/haproxy/haproxyprod.cfg -D -p /var/run/haproxyprod.pid  -sf $(cat /var/run/haproxyprod.pid)
# /usr/sbin/haproxy -f /etc/haproxy/haproxyqa.cfg -D -p /var/run/haproxyqa.pid  -sf $(cat /var/run/haproxyqa.pid)

repeat the same commands on haproxy-serv02 host

19.Check new certificates online and the the haproxy logs

# curl -vvI https://10.50.18.88:443|grep -Ei 'start date|expire date'

*       start date: Jul 15 08:19:46 2022 GMT
*       expire date: Jul 15 08:19:46 2025 GMT


You should get the new certificates Issueing start date and expiry date.

On both nodes (if necessery) do:

# tail -f /var/log/haproxy.log